How to Use the ProxyKing Wishlist to Plan a Future Order
TLDR
Open https://proxyking.biz/wishlist/ from the Wishlist link in the ProxyKing header, then use it as a shortlist rather than a promise about price or stock. Save the exact card treatment you want when the live product page offers a wishlist control, review the list by deck role, and reopen every listing before checkout. Keep quantities and deck assignments in a separate note unless those fields are visibly available on the current Wishlist page.
Start with the card decisions, not the catalog
A useful wishlist begins with a job: fixing a mana base, testing an expensive staple, assembling an artifact package, or collecting options for a Cube update. Starting with “cards I might want someday” is how a planning tool becomes a digital junk drawer with a Mox Diamond buried under twelve speculative sideboard ideas.
Before browsing, make a short list of roles your order needs to fill. For a Commander deck, that might include two lands, one repeatable draw engine, two pieces of interaction, and a card you want to test before considering an official copy. If you are unsure what deserves priority, use the guide to MTG proxy staples with high testing value to rank cards by what they will actually teach you.
Open the Wishlist and find the exact listing
ProxyKing’s global header currently provides separate Account and Wishlist links, along with product search and cart information. The Wishlist link leads to the site’s /wishlist/ page. You can open that page first, but card selection should happen from the catalog or an individual product listing.
Use search when you already know the card name. Use categories when you are comparing a broader package. The MTG catalog is divided into areas including lands, artifacts, proxy sets, colors, multicolored cards, and colorless cards. That taxonomy is particularly useful when your plan says “improve fixing” rather than “buy this exact Forest with delusions of grandeur.”
On the current product page, check for a visible wishlist or save control. If one appears, use it and then return to the Wishlist page to confirm that the intended item was added. The verified interface does not establish a universal control label or location, so follow what the live page displays rather than hunting for a button described in an older guide.
Confirm the printing and treatment before saving
The card name alone may not identify the product you want. ProxyKing can list several treatments of the same card; the land catalog, for example, has displayed regular, borderless, and extended-art versions of Boseiju, Who Endures. Read the complete listing title and inspect the product page before saving it.
Individual listings may include the card name, printing or treatment, price, availability, SKU, color identity, card type, rules text, and sometimes legality or ruling information. The information shown varies by listing, so verify the details that matter for your order rather than assuming every version is interchangeable.
- Card name and exact treatment
- Current price and availability
- Whether the version fits the visual style of the deck or Cube
- Card type, color identity, and rules text where relevant
- Whether you need one copy or several copies across different projects
Choose singles or a complete package
Wishlist planning is most useful when it reveals that several individual choices are really one package. ProxyKing’s MTG Proxy Sets category has included fetch, shock, dual, and triome land cycles, along with medallion, equipment-sword, and Power Nine sets. Compare the relevant set with the individual listings before filling the Wishlist with every component separately.
Choose singles when only a few cards solve the problem or when you want specific treatments. Consider a set when you are testing a complete mana cycle, building a reusable Cube module, or assembling a related package. If the goal is honest mana testing, the guide to proxying a mana base without warping results can help you avoid upgrading every land merely because the catalog made it possible.
Organize the Wishlist into an order plan
Do not assume the Wishlist supports quantities, private notes, sharing, restock alerts, or deck labels unless those controls are visible when you use it. Keep a simple companion note with one line per saved product.
| Field | What to record |
|---|---|
| Deck or project | The Commander deck, Cube, battle box, or testing package |
| Role | Fixing, ramp, draw, interaction, payoff, or cosmetic choice |
| Quantity | How many copies you actually intend to order |
| Priority | Now, next order, or speculative |
| Alternative | A cheaper, narrower, or currently available substitute |
| Test question | What you want to learn by playing the card |
That final field keeps the order focused. “Does this improve my opening hands?” is a useful test. “It is expensive and therefore probably majestic” is not.
Recheck every saved product before checkout
A wishlist records interest; it should not be treated as a reservation or price guarantee. Retrieved ProxyKing category pages included both available and out-of-stock products, while some set listings showed promotional prices. Reopen each live listing immediately before ordering and confirm the treatment, price, stock status, and quantity.
Available catalog cards may show an Add to cart option, while unavailable cards may be marked Out of stock and direct shoppers to Read more. If your saved version is unavailable, compare another treatment or keep it for a later order rather than silently substituting the wrong printing.
Review the current ProxyKing Shipping Policy before using a shipping threshold or delivery method to shape the order. In the retrieved policy, most orders were processed within one business day, peak processing could take up to three business days, and eligible orders of at least $75 could qualify for free shipping at checkout. Rates, eligibility, and service options can change, so the live policy and checkout are the final checks.
Use the Wishlist for responsible playtesting
A future order is easier to justify when every card has a testing purpose. ProxyKing describes its cards as unofficial proxy or playtest cards for casual games, agreed Commander pods, Cubes, playtesting, and organizer-permitted unsanctioned events. Review the current Proxy Use Policy and talk to your group before turning the Wishlist into a deck upgrade package.
For sanctioned events, Wizards states that cards must be authentic Magic cards, apart from limited judge-issued proxies for cards damaged during that event. Wizards’ proxy policy explains that distinction. A wishlist for casual testing is useful; a wishlist built around sneaking proxies into sanctioned play is merely an administrative record of a bad plan.
The best final review takes five minutes
Open the Wishlist, remove cards that no longer answer a real deckbuilding question, and group the remainder by project and priority. Compare singles with any relevant set, confirm the exact art or treatment, reopen every product page, and check the current shipping terms. If a deck contains several saved power upgrades, revisit ProxyKing’s Rule 0 scripts before game night as well.
The goal is not to make the longest wishlist. It is to build a short, verified order plan in which every card has a destination, a role, and a reason to be tested.
References
- Trust Center – Proxy King
- MTG Proxy Cards – Proxy King for Kitchen Table and Commander
- Land MTG Proxy Cards – Proxy King – Quality Proxies for Commander and Cube
- Fastbond – MTG Proxy Unlimited – Proxy King
- MTG Proxy Sets – Proxy King – Premium Magic the Gathering Proxy Cards
- Shipping Policy – Proxy King
- MTG Proxy Cards – Proxy King for Kitchen Table and Commander
- On Proxies, Policy, and Communication | MAGIC: THE GATHERING