Ranking the Best MtG Mana Rocks for Commander

If you want to build a competitive MtG deck in Commander, ramp is super important. Mana rocks are artifacts that can produce mana. This can give you a leg up early in the game because you can play as many of them on your turn as you can afford.

Mana rocks let you drop beefier creatures or spells faster than your opponents. As a result, they are central to virtually any competitive constructed format.

The most broken mana rocks must be the OG Moxen from Power 9. But, of course, these are banned in most formats, so we won’t be covering them today.

I’m writing this article with Commander in mind. EDH (and cEDH) is the perfect format for Mana Rocks since you can use so many different ones. Of course, you can totally apply this information to other formats like Pioneer and Modern.

Without further ado, here is the list. Read on for all the details.

S-Tier Mana Rocks – Must have Mana Rocks

This section is reserved for what I am calling the Holy Trinity. These three mana rocks have virtually no downsides.

Sol Ring:

Sol Ring epitomizes Commander like no other card. It comes with almost every preconstructed deck and is practically mandatory for casual and competitive play alike. You can drop a 4 CMC bomb on turn two. Or, if you get lucky on the draw, it can lead to an even more epic start. Turn 1 Sol Ring, tap for two, cast Talisman of Dominance, tap for one, and cast Mana Vault. Your opponents will be crapping bricks, wondering what is coming on turn two with eight mana.

Some people want it banned, but let’s all admit that it makes the game more interesting.

Mana Crypt:

Mana Crypt is a high-risk, high-reward addition to any deck. It costs zero mana to cast and can tap for two mana immediately. Of course, the lightning bolt damage risk is a downside. That said, it accelerates the game. It gives you lots of mana off the bat but also hits your life total on a coin flip each turn. The downsides of Mana Crypt on muted in Commander since you start with 40 life.

The real reason most folks don’t run it is that it’s expensive. So get a Mana Crypt proxy for a few bucks and boost your game.

Arcane Signet:

This may be the best mana-fixing rock out there. It’s not as busted as the above two cards, but still great. In particular, for multi-colored decks – for three, four, or five-colored decks I’d call this mandatory.

Arcane Signet is better than other signets because it can be tapped on the turn it’s dropped.

A-Tier Mana Rocks – Almost Always Useful

The Medallion Set:

The Medallions aren’t technically mana rocks since they don’t produce mana. But I generally lump them in because the outcome is pretty much the same. The medallions have the effect of reducing the mana costs of spells. Since this effect applies to all spells played on a turn, they can actually do MORE work than typical mana rocks.

Medallions also grow in power throughout the game. With a Sapphire Medallion on the board, for example, you may play 1 spell per turn early game, 2-3 spells on a turn midgame, and more late game. Each of those spells’ CMC is reduced.

Medallions also stack. So if you have a bunch of multi-colored cards, you can bring down your mana costs by having several Medallions on the board.

If you can’t tell, I’m a big fan of Medallions. You can get the set of 5 Medallions in our shop for $15.

Chrome Mox:

Chrome Mox is a great, affordable, mana rock that works in any format. The best part about Chrome Mox is that it is a zero mana artifact. It can also help with mana-fixing, which is excellent for early game.

Chrome Mox has over 25 Top 8 finishes in Worlds and Pro Tours

It works through its ‘Imprint’ ability. This lets you effectively cycle a dud card in your hand for a powerful mana rock.

Mox Diamond:

Mox Diamond is basically an auto-include for cEDH. It’s a free mana rock that taps for any color. In many cases, this is well worth the price of a basic land. It’s excellent for mana fixing and has seen a lot of use in 4 color partner builds.

For more casual Commander pods, Mox Diamond also has its place. But it will be more dependent on the deck that you are running.

For land-centric commanders, it’s perfect. It’s also great for recursion decks (think Crucible of Worlds or Meren decks). Finally, I’d use it in almost any artifact-centered deck build.

Niche Mana Rocks – Good for Specific Situations

Lion’s Eye Diamond:

Lion’s Eye Diamond doesn’t get much play simply because of its massive price tag. You’ll be lucky to get your hands on one for $500. Luckily you can get our proxy version for just four doll hairs. That said, it is a very useful card in certain situations.

It’s a zero-cost artifact. When you sacrifice it, you discard your hand and can add three mana to your mana pool. This is another ideal card for graveyard decks. Who cares if you discard your hand if you can play everything from your graveyard anyway?

In this case, it is practically better than a Black Lotus, because it can get key cards into your graveyard on the first turn.

It’s also a shoo-in card for an “Ad Nauseam” based deck. It’s a good card to draw into because it doesn’t cause you to lose life and it increases your storm count.

Finally, use it with Infernal Tutor to turn it into Demonic Tutor, and net one mana.

The Great Henge:

The card is the GOAT of certain decks. A mono green, or stompy deck will make the Great Henge broken.

If you can reduce it’s casting cost by five or seven it’s definitely worth dropping, simply because the abilities are so powerful. It lets you ramp, and get card draw advantage.

That said, it’s not a good card outside of those specific decks. It’s just too mana intensive to play. Plus artifacts are very susceptible to cheap removal.

Why You Need Mana Rocks in Your Commander Decks

Mana rocks are crucial to Magic: The Gathering decks, especially in the Commander format, due to their ability to accelerate mana production, which is fundamental for casting spells and deploying strategies efficiently. In the Commander format, the importance of mana rocks is amplified due to the game’s structure, which involves a larger deck size (100 cards), a higher life total (40 points), and the potential for more varied and powerful spell casting compared to other formats.

Mana rocks serve several key roles in Commander decks:

Acceleration: They allow players to ramp up their mana resources faster than what would be possible by relying on land drops alone. This acceleration is vital for executing strategies and casting high-cost spells earlier in the game.
Color Fixing: Many Commander decks utilize multiple colors, making mana rocks invaluable for their ability to provide mana of any color. As a result, players are consistently free to cast spells of various colors without regard to their land base.
Efficiency: Mana rocks can be more efficient in terms of deck space and mana cost. For example, they often come into play with a lower mana investment than lands that produce multiple colors of mana, and they can make the deck more resilient against land destruction strategies.
Strategic Flexibility: Certain mana rocks offer additional benefits beyond mana production, such as card draw or the ability to tap for multiple mana of any color, adding layers of strategic depth and utility to a deck.

Given their importance, the selection and number of mana rocks in a Commander deck can significantly impact its performance. A balanced mix of mana rocks, along with other forms of mana acceleration and fixing, can provide a solid foundation for a deck’s mana base, supporting its overall strategy and increasing its competitiveness.

Conclusion

There you have it, folks. My picks for the best mana rocks for Commander. Let me know what you think. Did I miss some obvious ones? Do you think I am overestimating the power level of any of these? Leave a comment below.