Search
Search

Reviews of ProxyKing

If you’re considering ProxyKing for MTG proxies, it helps to see real-world comparisons and hands-on write-ups—not just product descriptions.

Read reviews and leave your own Trust Pilot review here:

https://www.trustpilot.com/review/proxyking.biz

Video Review: ProxyKing.biz vs PrintMTG.com (Comparison)

This video compares proxy cards ordered from ProxyKing.biz and PrintMTG.com, including side-by-side visuals and discussion of how they stack up.

Watch here:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A3RVXOw8rX4

What it’s useful for:

  • Seeing side-by-side print/finish differences
  • Getting a feel for what each site is “best at”
  • Understanding tradeoffs between realism vs workflow/bulk ordering

Written Review: Draftsim Tested ProxyKing

Draftsim published a hands-on review of ProxyKing that covers what you actually care about: ordering, card quality, pricing, and best use cases.

Read it here:
https://draftsim.com/proxyking-review/

Highlights (quick summary)

  • Quality: The reviewer describes the cards as high quality and convincing at a glance.
  • Best use case: The review frames ProxyKing as a strong fit when you want to proxy expensive staples, not when you want to proxy an entire deck.
  • Anti-misuse “tells”: The review calls out that experienced players can identify proxies (which the reviewer considers a positive because it discourages misuse).

Community Thread: ProxyKing Buyer Experience (Reddit)

This Reddit thread includes a buyer describing their experience and sharing photos.

Want to give a shoutout to Proxy King – great quality and service!
byu/Cultural-Row23 inbootlegmtg
Proxy King review
byu/Drogo10 inbootlegmtg

https://www.reddit.com/r/bootlegmtg/comments/eqhl4f/proxy_king_review/

Ordered From Proxyking.biz
byu/tacticoolmonkey inbootlegmtg
Where to buy nice proxies
byu/brave-blade inCompetitiveEDH

Highlights (quick summary)

  • The posters report a positive experience, quick arrival, and satisfaction with the look of the cards.
  • Readers ask follow-up questions (coloration, backs, etc.), and the thread includes ongoing discussion.

What These Reviews Say

  • High-quality proxies for casual play / playtesting
  • A small set of specific staples (especially expensive cards)
  • A more “single-card storefront” buying style (vs decklist paste tools)

Common tradeoffs mentioned across third-party coverage:

  • ProxyKing is less ideal for bulk “entire deck” printing than services built around decklist uploads.
  • Realistic print/feel discussions exist online—so your best move is to be clear and consistent: casual only, not sanctioned, never resell as real.

Reminder: ProxyKing cards are intended for casual play and playtesting only. They are not tournament-legal for Wizards-sanctioned events and must never be represented or resold as authentic Magic cards. (See: https://proxyking.biz/proxy-use-policy/)

Helpful Links