If you’re considering ProxyKing for MTG proxies, it helps to see real-world comparisons and hands-on write-ups—not just product descriptions.
Read reviews and leave your own Trustpilot review here:
https://www.trustpilot.com/review/proxyking.biz
Video Review: ProxyKing.biz vs PrintMTG.com (Comparison)
This video compares proxy cards ordered from ProxyKing.biz and PrintMTG.com, including side-by-side visuals and discussion of how they stack up.
ProxyKing.biz and PrintMTG.com Review and Comparison — MTG Proxy Cards
Watch here:
What it’s useful for:
- Seeing side-by-side print and finish differences
- Getting a feel for what each service is best at
- Understanding tradeoffs between realism and bulk ordering workflows
Written Review: Draftsim Tested ProxyKing
Draftsim published a hands-on review of ProxyKing that covers ordering, card quality, pricing, and best use cases.
Read it here:
https://draftsim.com/proxyking-review
Highlights:
- Quality: The reviewer describes the cards as high quality and convincing at a glance.
- Best use case: The review frames ProxyKing as a strong fit for proxying expensive staples, rather than printing an entire deck.
- Anti-misuse “tells”: The review notes that experienced players can identify proxies, which can help discourage misuse.
Community Thread: ProxyKing Buyer Experience (Reddit)
These Reddit discussions include buyer experiences and photos:
- Proxy King review: https://www.reddit.com/r/bootlegmtg/comments/eqhl4f/proxy_king_review/
- Other community discussions include threads titled “Ordered From Proxyking.biz” and “Where to buy nice proxies.”
The discussions include reports of positive experiences, quick arrival, and satisfaction with the cards’ appearance. Readers also discuss coloration, card backs, and other details.
What These Reviews Say
Common themes in third-party coverage include:
- High-quality proxies for casual play and playtesting
- A focus on selected staples, especially expensive cards
- A more single-card storefront buying experience compared with services built around importing a full decklist
Common tradeoffs include:
- ProxyKing may be less convenient for bulk entire-deck printing than services built around decklist uploads.
- Realism and print-feel discussions exist online, so buyers should understand the intended use and limitations.
Responsible-use reminder: ProxyKing cards are intended for casual play and playtesting only. They are not tournament-legal for Wizards-sanctioned events and must never be represented or resold as authentic Magic cards.
Read the Proxy Use Policy: